Water Heater Replacement (Traditional Tank) in Murrieta: When It's Time for a New One

Member of the Chamber of Southwest Riverside County and the Temecula Valley Chamber of Commerce

Signs Your Tank Water Heater Is Failing

Quick Summary:

Tank water heaters will almost always give signs of impending doom before they actually fail. Some common ones we see include rusty hot water, popping sounds from the tank, lukewarm shower water and wetness around the bottom of the tank. If you notice any of those signs it’s time to plan a replacement instead of finding out with an emergency call about your flooded garage.

Tank failure rarely happens without warning. However, too often tank owners ignore these warnings. After all, the tank is out of sight, perhaps in the garage or a closet. It hums along happily and quietly until it completely fails, flooding your floor.

Rusty water heater with a corroded drain valve leaking brown sediment onto a concrete floor, hose reel in the background

Here’s what we tell folks to watch for.

  • If the water from the hot tap comes out looking rusty or brown, the lining inside the water heater’s tank is beginning to break down.
  • If you hear popping or rumbling sounds, or it sounds like a kettle, it’s probably because of sediment at the bottom of the tank. The sound is created by the sediment cooking at the bottom of the tank.
  • Reason for Decreasing Hot Water: As the sediment builds up, it takes up space that could be holding hot water.
  • If there is water or rust streaks at the base of the tank, then a seam has begun leaking. Once this happens, it won’t undo itself.
  • It’s been over 10/12 years… It’s never been flushed. That’s quite a bit of deferred maintenance there.


Popping is also common around here due to the amount of minerals in our Murrieta water. Minerals will collect in the bottom of your water heater. The minerals are cooked into a hard shell by the burner. The burner has to work harder and stay on longer to get the heat through the minerals into the water, which raises your gas bill. Eventually, the tank will crack from overheating.
every single week, we see this.

Another common theme is somebody calling in on Saturday morning and saying the water went cold in their shower, and they went downstairs and the pilot was out and they lit it and everything’s fine. That’s OK. But if that happens again, then the whole water heater is going out. And it’s almost never the second time that it’s the last time.
Shine a flashlight on the bottom of the tank. Dry concrete and clean connections mean you have time to schedule a new one. Rust ring, moistness, or white crust on connections means you need to have your heater replaced ASAP. Better to choose when to have a new heater than leave it up to your old one to choose when to be replaced.

Repair Versus Replacement: Know the Difference

Contrary to popular belief, you may not always have to invest in a new tank when you wake up to a cold shower. We get lots of callers expecting the worst. But in many cases, we find that replacing a $30 part will get them back in business for another five years.

Anything on the water heater other than the steel tank can be repaired. Thermocouples, elements, gas control valves, limit switches and thermostats can all be removed from the heater and replaced. If your water heater is not leaking and holds water, and is under 8 years old it needs to be inspected. Chances are you can save a lot of money by not prematurely replacing the unit.

The tank, however, is another animal altogether.

If the tank itself has rusted through, it must be replaced; epoxy, clamps and welds don’t stand up well to 40 to 60 gallons of hot, pressured water. Other items may be repaired.

  • Water seeps/drips out of the bottom of the tank itself, not out of the fittings.
  • Does the hot water run brown/rusty even after running for a minute?
  • The unit is between 10-12 years old. This would be it’s second or third repair.
  • Does the toilet make a rumbling/popping sound that does not stop after flushing?
  • The tank has not been maintained throughout its lifetime and the sacrificial anode rod is absent.

Have we said it yet? The water here in Murrieta is HARD. It wrecks anode rods and accumulates in tanks quicker than most areas. We pull water heaters out of the Copper Canyon or Alta Murrieta tract that gave up at nine years. They are LABELED as having a life expectancy of TWELVE years. It’s not a matter of brand, it’s a matter of the baked-on minerals at the bottom of the tank.

Lastly, if the entire house is filled, it’s possible that you’re using too much hot water. If you’re finding yourself without enough hot water in no time at all, your water heater may be in tip-top shape but may be too small in size for your home’s needs.

What Happens During a Tank Water Heater Replacement

Customers tend to imagine a replacement to be much more involved and messy than it usually is. Unless your current unit is installed in a tight spot (i.e., in the corner of a tight garage, or an upstairs closet that’s accessed through a tight space) we can usually have a new tank in place and you back to enjoying hot showers in just 3-4 hours.

Completed Water Heater Replacement

Customers tend to imagine a replacement to be much more involved and messy than it usually is. Unless your current unit is installed in a tight spot (i.e., in the corner of a tight garage, or an upstairs closet that’s accessed through a tight space) we can usually have a new tank in place and you back to enjoying hot showers in just 3-4 hours.

Here’s how the day usually goes.

  • First, we’ll cut off the power/gas and cold water supply to the unit, hook up a hose, and run it outside to drain the old tank.
  • Our team will disconnect, remove, and haul away the old heater for disposal, saving you from that task.
  • Another important item is the condition of the platform, the pan, and vent. We check all of these items prior to installation and let you know if there is a problem BEFORE setting your tank, not AFTER.
  • New unit is set in place, leveled, and strapped. In California, two seismic straps, one in the upper third of the tank and the other in the lower third, are required, and California inspectors are looking for them.
  • We will hook up water supply, gas/electrical connection, T&P valve connection. We will make certain your drain is directed to a safe discharge area.
  • To commission the water heater: Fill tank with water, bleed air from hot water lines, start/turn on power, check for leaks at all connections.
  • Before we leave, we’ll set the thermostat, usually to about 120 degrees, and walk you through the use and location of the shutoff valves.

Step three is typically where homeowners are surprised. Many homes here in Murrieta built in the 90’s and even some in the 2000’s have the water heater in the garage on a raised platform. After twenty plus years the venting, expansion tank, strapping and other elements are not code. We cannot legally hook it back up the same way. Bringing these elements up to code is included in the job and explaining why is part of our job as well.

All work performed by a licensed plumber, license #886431. Get your hot water back the same afternoon.

Call now

Have questions? We’re happy to help.

+19516967100

Make an Appointment . MVP Murrieta Valley Plumbing is ready to help.

Permits and Code Requirements for California Homeowners

When it comes to tank water heater replacements in California, we see a lot of homeowners make the mistake of not getting the work permitted. Contrary to popular belief especially when told otherwise from a handyman, replacing your water heater IS permitted work in California. It’s supposed to go in the order of pull a city permit, get inspected, get signed off. We’ve seen time and time again that cutting corners will always come back to haunt the homeowner.

An unpermitted heater can come back to bite you literally. Say goodbye to some of your hard-earned cash when you sell your house or refinance on it, or file an insurance claim for water damage. When the inspector or adjuster asks for the heater’s permit, you’ll wish you had one, and end up paying to redo work you already paid for.

It is extremely important for the water heater to be properly strapped, since California law requires it in Riverside County. A 50 gallon water heater is holding around 400 pounds of water. In an earthquake the heater needs to be properly strapped on its thirds both at the top and bottom. We see this all the time in the older homes in Murrieta, where the heater is not properly strapped. There’s just a plumber’s strap that’s loose or even no strap at all.

Expansion tank protects your water heater and fixtures. Many houses here have main pressure regulators which results in a closed plumbing system. When water is heated, it expands. With nowhere for this expanded water to go, it causes great duress on your water heater and other fixtures. An expansion tank provides a place for this extra pressure to go.

Here’s a list of common items an inspector looks for when inspecting a tank replacement.

  • NOTE: Must be strapped to framing and not just into drywall with 2 seismic straps.
  • If heater is installed inside a garage or indoors, use drain pan and drain to approved location.
  • Temperature and pressure relief valve discharge pipe extends down within a few inches of floor.
  • Vent shall not sag, Gas unit vents are supposed to have rise.
  • The expansion tank, because this is a closed water system.
  • Gas line has a sediment trap and code-compliant flexible connector.And yes, we’ll also pull the permit and attend the inspection. We can save ourselves and you arguing with the inspector later, if everything is done correctly the first time around. For a fully-insured, licensed contracting company it’s not a favor, it’s what we should be doing.

 

And yes, we’ll also pull the permit and attend the inspection. We can save ourselves and you arguing with the inspector later, if everything is done correctly the first time around. For a fully-insured, licensed contracting company it’s not a favor, it’s what we should be doing.

Watch Our Video

See How We Handle Water Heater Replacement (traditional tank) in Murrieta

Insert YouTube Video Link Here:

How Tank Replacement Pricing Works

Here’s the part everybody wants to skip to. What’s this going to cost me?

Homeowner reviewing permit paperwork in Murrieta

Tank water heater quotes can be confusing because there’s a lot of information we’re not always sharing. A quote has four or five costs stacked up and the heater is just one. Labor, permits, removal, any code requirements the inspector makes us comply with all factor into a quote. This is why we could service two houses on the same street and give vastly different quotes. Both would be fair and honest.

Capacity and energy source will also affect price, as a 40 gallon gas unit will be in an entirely different price range than an 80 gallon, and going from electric to gas will affect installation labor costs as well.

Water heater replacement can be a surprisingly involved process. It is not uncommon for the job to begin as an appliance replacement, only to find that we need to install a drain pan, add seismic strapping required by the State of California, bring the venting up to code, install a new gas flex and new shutoffs, and add an expansion tank if there is a pressure regulator on the main. Many Murrieta homes have regulators but were plumbed without expansion tanks. We have seen water heaters strapped in creative ways twenty years ago that we cannot repeat. All of these items add up and can surprise our customers.

The difficulty of the job also can depend more than folks expect upon location. A replacement in a garage on a flat slab is straightforward; however, installation into an attic or tight closet will take a bit more time, particularly if we’re removing an existing tank from an attic or tight space.

Before you agree to anybody, consider the above.

  • Do you include the permit in the total or is that an additional cost?
  • If required by the building code, does the quote include seismic strapping, an expansion tank, and drain pan?
  • Who will remove and properly dispose of the old tank?
  • Is this a flat, unchanging fee, or is it an hourly rate that may go up?
  • Is the installer licensed? Can you show me there license number?

We won’t start any work until we’ve given you an estimate, saving you the charge. Unexpected and inconvenient is the best way to describe the timing of a busted water heater, so we’re glad to offer financing via Wisetack, plus discounts to seniors and military. We are a licensed plumber, License #886431. Ask any plumber for their license.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about Water Heater Replacement

How do I know if my water heater needs to be replaced or just repaired?

If the tank itself is rusted through or leaking from the seams, you need a replacement, not a repair. Parts like thermostats, elements, and gas control valves can often be replaced for a fraction of the cost. If your unit is under 8 years old, holds water, and isn’t leaking, have it inspected before assuming the worst. Tanks over 10-12 years old with no maintenance history are usually better off replaced.

Why do water heaters seem to fail faster in Murrieta than other places?

Murrieta’s hard water is the main reason. Minerals build up quickly at the bottom of the tank and get baked into a hard shell by the burner. We regularly pull water heaters out of homes in Copper Canyon and Alta Murrieta that failed at nine years, even though they’re rated for twelve. It’s not about brand quality. It’s about mineral buildup working against the tank every day.

What are the warning signs that my tank water heater is about to fail?

Rusty hot water, popping or rumbling noises, lukewarm showers, and moisture around the tank base are the big four. Popping sounds mean sediment is cooking at the bottom of the tank. Rust streaks or wetness at the base mean a seam has started leaking, and that won’t fix itself. A quick flashlight check on the tank base can tell you if you have time to plan or need action now.

How long does a tank water heater replacement take?

Most replacements take about 3-4 hours from start to finish. That includes draining the old tank, disconnecting and hauling it away, checking the platform and vent, and setting the new unit with seismic strapping. Tight spaces, like an upstairs closet or a cramped garage corner, can add time. We check the pan, platform, and vent before installing, so there are no surprises after the new tank is in place.

Do I need special straps or code requirements for a new water heater in California?

Yes, California requires two seismic straps on every water heater, one in the upper third of the tank and one in the lower third. Inspectors specifically check for this during permitting. It’s a code requirement, not optional equipment. When we install a replacement, this strapping is built into the process so your new unit passes inspection without any follow-up visits needed.

How often should I flush my water heater to avoid early failure?

Regular flushing, ideally once a year, clears out sediment before it hardens and shortens your tank’s life. Units that go a decade or more without flushing build up a thick mineral layer that makes the burner work harder and raises your gas bill. In Murrieta’s hard water, this buildup happens faster than in many other areas, so flushing matters even more here.

Ready to Get Started?

Make an Appointment . Call +19516967100 today.